Friday, December 23, 2005

Durai and Qin Hui

I wrote to the Straits Time Forum today with the following letter. Regardless of whether they are going to publish it, I am publishing it here:

In Chinese history, there was a man Qin Hui who was responsible for the execution of the national hero General Yue Fei. From the About.com article on Yue Fei, Qin Hui is someone "who wielded real power at court", and he managed to convince the then emperor to execute Yue Fei by imposing a "mo xu you" (fabricated charge) crime on the general.

Only after the next emperor succeeded the throne did the truth of Yue Fei's execution come to light. By then, the only way to punish Qin Hui was to (1) build a statue of him and his wife (still in a temple in Huang Zhou today) for people to spit on; and (2) write the story into the Chinese history books so that generations to come will know of the deeds.

TT Durai's deeds has uncannily mirrored that of Qin Hui. Wielding his power with the old NKF board, he made up many ways to pay himself excessively, and eventually brought Singapore's national pride, the NKF to become the national shame. Now the new board has succeeded the old board, and the wrongdoings come to light, there is no immediate way anyone can punish TT Durai.

We probably cannot erect a statue of TT Durai for public spitting, but we can include the wrongdoings into the Moral Education and Singapore History syllabus so that every generation of students will learn about the wrong deeds. This approach will achieve both the effect of educating our future generations, and also to punish TT Durai, without having to wait for the authorities to figure out whether any criminal charges can be brought against him.

3 comments:

Chris Sim said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Chris Sim said...

Hi Yong Koh,
Thanks for dropping by my blog. While I'm no fan of Durai, I think having his crime "entombed" in textbooks for the purpose of Moral Education is rather draconian. Sure, the man had done wrong and what he and the board of directors did can never by condoned. But let's teach our kids the kind act of forgiveness. After all, this is also what moral education is about. Merry Christmas!

Anonymous said...

rather than judging his wrong-doings, think also of the good he has done... afaik, qin hui has done nothing good for the song dynasty, unless the books were biased... not exactly an uncanny likeness...

if durai is found to have commited no crime, let it be the end...